What makes a good game?

The Scale is 1 to 5.
5 being a success, 1 being a failure.

  • Quality of the Visual Element,functionality of the game bits how they contribute to the gameplay?
    • 5 — is seamless, beautiful – robust, comfortable
    • 1 — Ugly , distracting, lazy – shoddy, uncomfortable, dysfunctional
  1. Does the level complexity of justify itself.
    • 5 — is perfect
    • 1 — too simple , too complex
  2. How clearly are the rules communicated.
    • 5 — excellent very clear
    • 1 — not clear, badly written, illustrated, (((Maybe heir achy  of text)))
  3. How original is the game theme, or narrative?
    • 5 — Original
    • 1 — Unoriginal
  4. How original is the game mechanics(the repeatable actions that contributes the most to the successful guy)) ?
    • 5 — never seen before
    • 1 — You remade monopoly (copycat, reskinned)
  5. how complain, immersive, fun, of entertaining  is the game and through out  play duration. ( 1 to 5 )
    • 5 — Facebook like button
    • 1 — wrong, thumb downs
  6. How well balanced is the game?
    • 5 — Balanced
    • 1 — Unbalanced
  7. Does the game have meaning choices
    • 5 — has meaningful choices
    • 1 — does not have meaningful choices
  8. Was the Sport adapted well ?
    • 5 — The game still retains elements from the original sport
    • 1 — The game departs greatly from the original game
  9. Was the Physical element contribute to the game experience.
    • 5 — Physical element greatly adds to the experience.
    • 1 — Physical element does not add to the experience of the game.